forums

Friday Recruiting Chatter - 11/30

View as article
gogeta4 said:
Travis Jay is a freak and one of my fav recruits this class. If we can somehow pull that kid out of Tally...Crown whomever does it.

I like All of the NYC kids. I also would of kept tabs on Dorlus though DB hasn't been good to us at all. Simpson follows Dorlus on twitter though so im sure he was aware of him
Click to expand...

Jay is criminally underrated.
 
Advertisement
Cuban-Cane said:
Thats not what he said. He said we got our number 1 guys. Sitkowski was that we got him then Williams became that and we got him too. We didn't strike our on anyone as you imposed.
Click to expand...

I'm not saying that we didn't take a QB last year. But the original post indicated that we got our "first choice," and this was decidedly not the case.

We scrambled for Williams, just like we seem to be scrambling now. If Williams really was the #1 guy last season, he should have been identified, courted, and locked up earlier. If we have to keep going through this song and dance year after year -- and by all indications, that's what's occurring now -- it'll eventually be something that bites us in the ***.
 
Mklein13 said:
Oh no he’s got an offer from Pitt. Shut it down he must be all world then.
Click to expand...

Look at Ian Book's offers coming out of high school and tell me how well that's working out for ND. Or Baker Mayfield's.

And another thing: some posts debating people who want to take a lower-ranked QB are guilty of false equivalency. No one is saying "bring in a three-star guy to be the starter!" (even though there is a possibility that it could work out). The argument is this: we don't know what we have with Perry or Williams yet, and each could get hurt. Weldon is almost certainly transferring. I'd much rather have:

1. Perry/Williams
2. Williams/Perry
3. Lower-ranked 3 star QB

as the depth chart next season, as opposed to:

1. Perry/Williams
2. Williams/Perry
3. Walk on.

In scenario #2, we are completely effed if Williams or Perry gets hurt. As an emergency option, I take option #1 every day of the week, and twice on Saturday.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
TimeB0mb said:
Jeeeeeeeeeeeezus this is awful.

In summary:
No qb, losing a once in a decade OL recruit and best LB recruit.

If Rick can't win and can't recruit, why exactly are we keeping him again?
Click to expand...
Thought Donaldson was once in a generation or was that Sentreal Henderson or Reggie Youngblood,or 5 star KC MCdermottt
 
Advertisement
Papo said:
Read this and thank me later fellas....Canes will have a top 10 class. Guaranteed!

Drop the mike........
Click to expand...

potato.webp
 
GladeCane said:
Can he move? If he can't dance don't offer.
Click to expand...
yeah that's what we need, another 4.5 QB that can't hit a receiver in stride... I'd take a deadly accurate QB with two fake legs over another dual threat QB that cant throw for crap or read a defense.
 
Advertisement
flcanesfan said:
yeah that's what we need, another 4.5 QB that can't hit a receiver in stride... I'd take a deadly accurate QB with two fake legs over another dual threat QB that cant throw for crap or read a defense.
Click to expand...
With our recent history of OL performance and the prospect that it will probably not improve greatly in the near future, we don't need another decently accurate stone footed QB like Brad Kaaya.
 
gogeta4 said:
Travis Jay is a freak and one of my fav recruits this class. If we can somehow pull that kid out of Madison...Crown whomever does it.

I like All of the NYC kids. I also would of kept tabs on Dorlus though DB hasn't been good to us at all. Simpson follows Dorlus on twitter though so im sure he was aware of him
Click to expand...
Yep them country boys in Madison are for real.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top