Start here:
In order to create the most comprehensive Team Recruiting Ranking without any notion of bias, 247Sports Team Recruiting Ranking is solely based on the 247Sports Composite Rating.
247sports.com
The criticism was that Cristobal teams "always look unprepared" and "poorly coached." Kiffin has shown many times he can coach circles around most coaches. UGA has far more talent (composite total: 1001, #2 overall) than Ole Miss (801, #20) , but Kiffin just took them behind the woodshed.
The GT game had an extra spotlight on it because of how last year's game ended with one of the worst coaching blunders of all time. One would think Cristobal would have the team ready to erase that memory. And there were also other losses last year where UM had a sizeable talent edge. But compare that to Ole Miss in 2023. 11-2, only losses to #2 UGA and at #13 Bama. Then Ole Miss beat #10 PSU in the Peach Bowl. Not one "slip-up" last year against an inferior team. Even going back to Cristobals best season ever as a HC, 2019. Oregon blew their chance at the playoffs with a loss at Arizona State. Talent level between those teams wasn't close.
You mention Ole Miss's loss to UK. Look at the composite talent level between Ole Miss and UK. Ole Miss and UK have about the same amount of talent- Ole Miss got beat by an
equally talented, but underperforming UK squad. Now look at the difference between UM and GT. MIami talent composite is 868 (#14). GT's is 702 (#46). Miami has FAR more talent than GT. Given the stakes, I have zero problem with McFarland's take, and there isn't a need to mention Kiffin/Ole Miss because Kiffin has established that he frequently has his teams prepared and well-coached. When he does get outcoached, it's surprising. On the flip side, if/when Cristobal ever outcoaches another HC, I think we can all agree it that is very likely that **** just froze over.