Do recruiting Stars Matter?

[Canedog]

I'm a star hoe, but I'm cool with a few 3 stars.

 

[TheOriginalCane]

I see so many people on here completely write off recruits who are a 3 Star or worse. I understand that the best teams have the most 5 Star Rankings but that doesn't mean a 3 Star recruit can't become Great! Just look a Greg Rousseau,D'Eriq King and Quincy Roche. 2 and 3 star recruits get drafted in the first round every year. I use to be a 4 and 5 Star **** but I've seen way to many of them fail on our team and then low star guys become Legends for us.

Stars matter. Development matters. Personal motivation and hard work matter.

But, yes, stars matter.

 

[Trafficante]

Stars matter. Development matters. Personal motivation and hard work matter.

But, yes, stars matter.

Exactly. There are many factors & variables that influence & determine why a team wins a championship. Stars are only one of many. You can't just isolate 1 variable in order to fit a narrative. To understand why you have to perform a multi-variate analysis.

 

[Memnon]

You do realize some people haven't followed every single thread in here for the last several years right? How was I supposed to know this subject has been brought up several times in here. Ive only been active in here the last couple months.

You're right, my apologies.

 

[CrooKs]

You're right, my apologies.

My dude El has been getting snarky here lately. And here I thought all this coaching turnover had you excited again lol

 

[01Falsetto]

Yes but it’s not the be all end all

 

[HarryCarayisGoat]

This is CIS mang:

If they commit to us, stars matter bigtime.
if they don’t commit to us, stars don’t mean **** and we never wanted the 5 star bum to begin with.

 

[South Side Chi Cane]

I see so many people on here completely write off recruits who are a 3 Star or worse. I understand that the best teams have the most 5 Star Rankings but that doesn't mean a 3 Star recruit can't become Great! Just look a Greg Rousseau,D'Eriq King and Quincy Roche. 2 and 3 star recruits get drafted in the first round every year. I use to be a 4 and 5 Star **** but I've seen way to many of them fail on our team and then low star guys become Legends for us.

You been around here long enough to hear this topic be beat to death. You bored ?