Class of 2024 Defensive Back Ryan Mack Commits to Miami Hurricanes

[Fzac75]

The reality he looks like he will come in and contribute early . Accordingly to this board 5 star Scott and 4 star jones want be ready . Why are they ranked so high if they’re not ready and this kid seems ready now . They need to stop handing out 5 star unless they’re ready day 1 . That supposed to be the best of the best. Taylor 5 star probably should have been a 3 star he was average at best

Two different positions. History has shown at the line of scrimmage most of the times incoming freshman are not physically ready to be a real contributor and effective. There is a difference physically between and 18-19 year old kid who just started a real S&C regimen going up against a 21-22 who has been at it now a couple of years. The simple physical maturity is not there to be a real contributor and make an impact. There are always exceptions but normally thats the case.

The skill positions is a little less physically demanding as opposed to the LOS. Speed and quickness and acceleration are the first prerequisite for a DB physically. Strength training, which is still needed, but for that position is not the end all be all for quality contributions, and is why you see underclassmen be able to contribute quicker and you can have a realistic hope of that possibility.

Regardless of stars LOS players typically don’t contribute right away


Just my two cents

 

[JennStrawley’sBabyDaddy]

The reality he looks like he will come in and contribute early . Accordingly to this board 5 star Scott and 4 star jones want be ready . Why are they ranked so high if they’re not ready and this kid seems ready now . They need to stop handing out 5 star unless they’re ready day 1 . That supposed to be the best of the best. Taylor 5 star probably should have been a 3 star he was average at best

From their explanation, the rankings are for future projections. So a 5 star is a kid they see having a high ceiling that’s a future 1st rounder.

 

[Mikesmith29150]

 

[NorthEastCane]

The reality he looks like he will come in and contribute early . Accordingly to this board 5 star Scott and 4 star jones want be ready . Why are they ranked so high if they’re not ready and this kid seems ready now . They need to stop handing out 5 star unless they’re ready day 1 . That supposed to be the best of the best. Taylor 5 star probably should have been a 3 star he was average at best

That's not their criteria. Stars are a projection of (1) where they believe they will be drafted and (2) whether they have potential to reach All American status. That is, once completing their college career.

The expectation that they will be day 1 ready is a CIS thing.

 

[5XNC]

Rod and samari rolle train at my gym. Ryan came in a few times before leaving for UM

 

[JHallCanes]

Rod and samari rolle train at my gym. Ryan came in a few times before leaving for UM

That position has already been filled but we will keep your application on file

 

[JayCane20]

Pictures can be deceiving but looks like he belongs here physically and could contribute this year.

That wasn't the case when I saw him in person back in October. Kid must have put in the work this winter.