Don't remember McGuire on any national recruiting lists back then. He won the high school Heisman from the NYAC the same year Vinny won the college Heisman. I don't know how we found out about him. He won that NYAC award probably because he was a NYC kid.
We got some other RBs from the NY-NJ area the same year, I think: Ellery Roberts, Tekay Dorsey and one kid from Florida I think. The only one who was a player was McGuire. I remember Max Emfinger telling me how good Roberts was going to be for Miami. This was early in fall practice. Roberts had already made his mark as a flop according to my friends. I think Emfinger had Roberts, who was from Long Island, as a five star. Emfinger was dumbfounded when I told him, just a few weeks into fall practice, that Roberts was a flop. Emfinger became Dumbfinger. My sources were right. I don't know if Roberts lasted the whole year. He ended up transferring to Stanford, which was not very good at the time. Dorsey lasted a few years and transferred to Rutgers. I think our fourth back might have been a kid named Terrell Jackson and some were promsing he was the second coming of Mel Bratton. He was not.
McGuire was the only kid from that recruiting class of four RBs who did anything--if I've got the class right. It's been some years, and I'm not sure my memory serves me well, but I think those were the four we recruited in a year we really needed backs. Didn't McGuire spend a year at Fork Union, by the way?