TheMatador
All-ACC
- Joined
- Jan 30, 2012
- Messages
- 13,849
This stuff goes both ways. Kids commit and they keep looking. Schools offer and sometimes accept commits from kids, and they keep looking. It's the head coach who allows a 17 year old kid decide his professional fate that is the loser in all of this. Unfortunately UM has had a lot of that with Coker, Shannon and Golden. Saban, Urban, Miles, and others do not for 1 second allow 1 kid to have that much control over their programs. If they commit and go on trips, they lose their spot. I'm sure there are exceptions, but that's how 4 and 5 star generals get it done when they're at the pinnacle of college football. UM hires nice, polite 1 star generals who end up 1 or 2 games off of .500 every year for the last 12, and they get run over by medium and above teams, as well as top notch recruits.
Reminds me of one of the U 30 for 30s. I can't remember which player it was (Highsmith maybe), but in his first meeting Schnelly told him he was going to redshirt. He asked Highsmith (or whoever it was) "do you have a problem with that?" The general put the soldier in his place and the conversation was over.
Schnelly lied all around (the sign of a good recruiter). Not only did he not redshirt Highsmith, he switched him to offense. Who knows what kind of career he would have had on defense. He was a first round choice anyway, but didn't have much of a pro career, I guess 'cause his knees were bad.
In fact, it probably was not Highsmith. It probably was somebody like Bratton, who did redshirt. Redshirt was much more accepted back then, as was staying for four years. Different era entirely.
This is all BS about Golden being weak and permitting people to look around. The sad fact is, if we laid down the law to these kids, and gave them ultimatums, most of them would walk. We don't have the leverage over these kids, and we never really have. A myth of these boards is that we were always all powerful in recruiting, and used to get only four and five stars. The fact is, we were never that strong with the elite recruits, and built our success on the less appreciated kids with high potential. That was true with Butch, and it was true with Jimmy. We probably got a lot more elite recruits with Howard, especially his last couple of classes.
But keep believing what you want to believe. Most of you don't know the history.