forums

Alltime Greatest Hurricane Position

Man Of Steel said:
OL is a very underrated with the amount of OL WE have in the league.
Click to expand...

155.gif
 
Advertisement
MIA42178 said:
Start with our championship teams and go with the common denominators

based on college performance

Kosar, Kelly, Testeverde, Toretta, Dorsey

based on pro performance

DTs
Click to expand...

You listed two QBs that didn't win championships, but still belong on the list, and left out two that did--Walsh and Erickson. Leaving Mira off the list also is a blunder, I think.

Based on pro performance, along with DT, we have some battles with other positions:

WR: Brown, Irvin, Perriman, Blades, Moss, Wayne, Johnson (potentially three HOF members there)
RB: Boessler, Banaszak, Foreman, Anderson, James, Portis, McGahee, Gore

UM is pretty stacked in the "Pro Football Successes" department.
 
Going off pro performance.

At DT, we have two HOFers (Sapp and Kennedy), plus Brown, who was better than both and would have gotten there, Wilfork, Maryland (No. 1 overall), Burt, Dunn, etc.

At S, we have Reed (HOFer for sure), plus ST (who would have gotten there), plus Blades, plus D. Williams, Marion, KP, Meriweather, Owens et al.

At QB, we have Kelly (HOF), Testaverde and Toretta (Heisman), Walsh, Dorsey (top 2 Heisman), Kosar, Erickson....

At WR, we have Irvin (HOF), Wayne (may get there), AJ, Moss, Hill, E. Brown et al.

At DE, you have Hendricks (HOF, GOAT CFB DE), Edwards, Medearis, ***an, Stubbs, Holmes, Lang, Patrick, Campbell,

At LB, you have the GOAT (Lewis), plus a lot of very very good guys, but there isn't that second other guy like you have at some other spots. Armstead may have had the best pro career other than Lewis.

Gotta be QB or DT, IMO. Close call at DE, S.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top