Yeah - the proposal where the 1st place team team doesn't play in the ACC title game seems odd to me, but at least makes some sense if the goal is to get as many teams from the ACC into the playoff as possible It still feel like it would cheapen the champion though, like this year if SMU was given the ACC title and the winner of Clemson/Miami in the ACC Championship Game was #2...
The proposal to add a playoff to the ACC championship, while I could see if it from a "let's make more money!" point of view, I have to imagine at some point someone is going to push back on the amount of games being played. You are now talking about at the ACC Champion having played 14 before even getting to the playoffs.