forums

About time NIL HS in FL

Advertisement
giphy.gif
 
Advertisement
Home Slice said:
Had to happen in this very different era of "amateur " athletics we are in
Click to expand...

What still shocks me is that NIL, upon its purest argument, was never meant for any of this, especially HS athletes.

It was designed for enrolled college athletes to be compensated for whenever their name, image, or likeness was used in any monetary capacity, and prohibit the NCAA to deem their amateur status ineligible if they were to commercialize & monetize off their N.I.L.

But, whenever u get politics involved in things that’s not truly in their purview, well u get this.
 
Rellyrell said:
What still shocks me is that NIL, upon its purest argument, was never meant for any of this, especially HS athletes.

It was designed for enrolled college athletes to be compensated for whenever their name, image, or likeness was used in any monetary capacity, and prohibit the NCAA to deem their amateur status ineligible if they were to commercialize & monetize off their N.I.L.

But, whenever u get politics involved in things that’s not truly in their purview, well u get this.
Click to expand...
No, NIL was not invented for college athletes. The laws simply gives student athletes the same rights as all other American citizens when it comes to profiting off of their name image and likeness. Rights restored. Not the other way around.
 
Rellyrell said:
What still shocks me is that NIL, upon its purest argument, was never meant for any of this, especially HS athletes.

It was designed for enrolled college athletes to be compensated for whenever their name, image, or likeness was used in any monetary capacity, and prohibit the NCAA to deem their amateur status ineligible if they were to commercialize & monetize off their N.I.L.

But, whenever u get politics involved in things that’s not truly in their purview, well u get this.
Click to expand...
💯 it evolved at warp speed. aTm helped create the monster "legally " if you will.
 
Advertisement
Rellyrell said:
What still shocks me is that NIL, upon its purest argument, was never meant for any of this, especially HS athletes.

It was designed for enrolled college athletes to be compensated for whenever their name, image, or likeness was used in any monetary capacity, and prohibit the NCAA to deem their amateur status ineligible if they were to commercialize & monetize off their N.I.L.

But, whenever u get politics involved in things that’s not truly in their purview, well u get this.
Click to expand...

I see your point which is they should just call it like it is — pay to play. But there is definitely an NIL component involved and now it’s only going to get greater. We had athletic and footwear companies throwing “free” gear at the best athletes back in the 80s. That’s a NIL deal just not direct cash benefit. We’ve had “uncles” handling bags for colleges since then too. Maybe the colleges will have to sponsor kids now? At least this takes it out of the shadows. I am for it.
 
mik303 said:
No, NIL was not invented for college athletes. The laws simply gives student athletes the same rights as all other American citizens when it comes to profiting off of their name image and likeness. Rights restored. Not the other way around.
Click to expand...

Lol; no…that wasn’t the argument or the case, friend. Like, not remotely close, actually. Lol.

I don’t have the time nor the patience to meticulously dissect and outline all of this, plus a simple search will take u to these pages. What transpired was the NCAA said F it, we don’t want to be involved or potentially get sued, so they threw together vague language w/ plenty of leeway for loop holes which have been egregiously exploited.

What u just stated is the cause effect of what has transpired, NOT what was brought to the Supreme Court or ruled upon.
 
gogeta4 said:
yea the head coaches...every one else is working for free and losing money or 2-4k if they are lucky.

the fhsaa is a sham...

ninjas created different random divisions because south florida sweeps the state champ games and we play our state champ games in regular high school level stadiums smh
Click to expand...
coaches at schools like IMG make bank tho? just curious, but private vs public correct?
 
grover said:
I see your point which is they should just call it like it is — pay to play. But there is definitely an NIL component involved and now it’s only going to get greater. We had athletic and footwear companies throwing “free” gear at the best athletes back in the 80s. That’s a NIL deal just not direct cash benefit. We’ve had “uncles” handling bags for colleges since then too. Maybe the colleges will have to sponsor kids now? At least this takes it out of the shadows. I am for it.
Click to expand...

Free Gear is still being thrown around at camps & events, that haven’t changed.

N.I.L has become blurred w/ pay to play, & quite frankly it’s a double edge sword. It’s why I don’t become invested in recruiting nor do I become invested in players on the team b/c I know at any given moment, they can bounce, even if u r giving them all they want.
 
Advertisement
Rellyrell said:
Lol; no…that wasn’t the argument or the case, friend. Like, not remotely close, actually. Lol.

I don’t have the time nor the patience to meticulously dissect and outline all of this, plus a simple search will take u to these pages. What transpired was the NCAA said F it, we don’t want to be involved or potentially get sued, so they threw together vague language w/ plenty of leeway for loop holes which have been egregiously exploited.

What u just stated is the cause effect of what has transpired, NOT what was brought to the Supreme Court or ruled upon.
Click to expand...
You should run for the mayor of Beijing
 
Rellyrell said:
What still shocks me is that NIL, upon its purest argument, was never meant for any of this, especially HS athletes.

It was designed for enrolled college athletes to be compensated for whenever their name, image, or likeness was used in any monetary capacity, and prohibit the NCAA to deem their amateur status ineligible if they were to commercialize & monetize off their N.I.L.

But, whenever u get politics involved in things that’s not truly in their purview, well u get this.
Click to expand...


Matter of time...


1717517587088.png
 
Advertisement
Rellyrell said:
& u should learn reading comprehension
Click to expand...
Are you really angry that HS kids can make money from their name Image and likeness? Is this real? Why are you so triggered? Are you doing like a "devils advocate" skit or something?
 
mik303 said:
Are you really angry that HS kids can make money from their name Image and likeness? Is this real? Why are you so triggered? Are you doing like a "devils advocate" skit or something?
Click to expand...

Again, READING is fundamental. Did u see anything about me being angry about HS kids & NIL? I stated what the purpose of NIL was & how it spiraled.

My only gripe w/ NIL under its current construct is the pay for play, & truly it’s pay for play while kids on a roster r looking to bully their way to more money or leave.

That’s it.
 
Rellyrell said:
What still shocks me is that NIL, upon its purest argument, was never meant for any of this, especially HS athletes.

It was designed for enrolled college athletes to be compensated for whenever their name, image, or likeness was used in any monetary capacity, and prohibit the NCAA to deem their amateur status ineligible if they were to commercialize & monetize off their N.I.L.

But, whenever u get politics involved in things that’s not truly in their purview, well u get this.
Click to expand...
Wow someone with a brain that makes sense. High school NIL is beyond stupid. It’s ridiculous. You think tampering is bad in college? This is a joke.

And I don’t care about NIL because I hate the NCAA but the wild Wild West approach us ******** up college athletics. And the transfer portal would be fixed in ten seconds if kids could go wherever they want but had to sit a year but still get that year without losing time. That will solve most of the BS. But your post was sensible and right on.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top