Week 12 college football thoughts...

k9cane

Senior
Joined
Nov 20, 2011
Messages
9,099
Another great Footballpalooza at Coach JB's Football Bar and Cigar Lounge (which was capped off by UFC 309 -- yes, we watched it)..

- Colorado continues to rack up victories. As always, Shaduer Sanders and Travis Hunter will be spotlighted, but the way the Buffs have gotten better defensively is overlooked. Guys like Nikhai Green-Hill and LaVonta Bentley real thumpers, and Amari McNeill have steadily improved. CU is actually a well-rounded team

As for Utah, it's too bad that their QB situation turned out the way it did. It really had an impact on the rest of their team


- The demise of Georgia was exaggerated. But for them to protect their home turf wasn't that big of a surprise. If they get that version of Carson Beck the rest of the way, there are still very few teams that can play with them. As for the Vols, Nico I. has been a disappointment. Not only has he not been worth $8 million, he's not playing at the Hendon Hooker-level, and to be fair, he doesn't have a Jalen Hyatt or Cedric Tillman surrounding him.

- Wasn't completely surprised by Kansas upsetting BYU. The Cougars are another team (like Miami) that had lived on the edge and you get the sense that there would be a week where that caught up to them. The Jayhawks are several plays away from being an 8 win team. They are better than their record

- I see a lot being made over Brian Kelly screaming and yelling at his players. Bottom line, to me, that's old-school coaching. I don't mind it. Football is a tough game. But in today's culture, the optics will not be in his favor. It is what it is. My view is, when you're winning, it will be accepted and even lauded as being tough and having a sound culture of accountability. But when you're a disappointing team like LSU, well, it will be critisized.

- Im a fan of coach Brohm at L'Ville, but his decision making at the end of the Stanford game was a clinic on how to throw away a game. The simple decision was to just punt and take the game to overtime. Instead it became Murphy's Law that last 30 seconds

- Notre Dame is rolling. Yeah, you can continue to point to the Northern Illinois loss, but they are getting what they wanted from Riley Leonard at quarterback.

- Why has the Heisman talk on Ashton Jeanty died down? At the very least, he should be invited to New York in December.

- Anyone notice the job Kenny Dillinghman is doing at Arizona State in year 2? He should be in the coach of the year discussion.

- Miami had a bye week, so we were all spared from watching that defense. The bottom line for the #Canes is very simple -- it's a three game playoff to get to the playoffs. Lose one, and you're out. Complain all you want about the rankings and bias (I get it) but the ACC is only getting one team in the 12-team tourney
 
Advertisement
If Miami cruises the next 2 and loses a really close ACC championship game?? Maybe they find a way to get them in at 11 or 12 and make them go on the road so everyone tunes in to see them lose? It's possible. I guess it depends on how other teams go
 
The Deion Tax will be insufferable if Colorado wins the Big 12 and a Top 4 seed. And deserved. Sanders should be in the Coach of the Year discussions. His haters were hoping for a complete collapse this year and it went the opposite way.
 
Advertisement
- Miami had a bye week, so we were all spared from watching that defense. The bottom line for the #Canes is very simple -- it's a three game playoff to get to the playoffs. Lose one, and you're out. Complain all you want about the rankings and bias (I get it) but the ACC is only getting one team in the 12-team tourney
Miami wins and the Cam Show continues, but with our history of Nov collapse on line any loss in next two games and it ends abruptly as we miss ACC championship and he opts out of bowl..

Hoping we get atleast 4 more games and a good month of publicity to close for recruiting.. which we need a dam near whole DB backfield from portal.. Lose and its 2 games and it was fun while it lasted..

My gawd this defense smfh..
 
My hot take after week 12 is the same as it’s been all season.

Anyone in the top 40 can beat anyone on a given Saturday. It all comes down to a handful of plays to change a game.

The game is now survive and advance.
agreed the parity is really evident. Everyone has either lost or barely gotten by vs supposed inferior teams.
 
Another great Footballpalooza at Coach JB's Football Bar and Cigar Lounge (which was capped off by UFC 309 -- yes, we watched it)..

- Colorado continues to rack up victories. As always, Shaduer Sanders and Travis Hunter will be spotlighted, but the way the Buffs have gotten better defensively is overlooked. Guys like Nikhai Green-Hill and LaVonta Bentley real thumpers, and Amari McNeill have steadily improved. CU is actually a well-rounded team

As for Utah, it's too bad that their QB situation turned out the way it did. It really had an impact on the rest of their team


- The demise of Georgia was exaggerated. But for them to protect their home turf wasn't that big of a surprise. If they get that version of Carson Beck the rest of the way, there are still very few teams that can play with them. As for the Vols, Nico I. has been a disappointment. Not only has he not been worth $8 million, he's not playing at the Hendon Hooker-level, and to be fair, he doesn't have a Jalen Hyatt or Cedric Tillman surrounding him.

- Wasn't completely surprised by Kansas upsetting BYU. The Cougars are another team (like Miami) that had lived on the edge and you get the sense that there would be a week where that caught up to them. The Jayhawks are several plays away from being an 8 win team. They are better than their record

- I see a lot being made over Brian Kelly screaming and yelling at his players. Bottom line, to me, that's old-school coaching. I don't mind it. Football is a tough game. But in today's culture, the optics will not be in his favor. It is what it is. My view is, when you're winning, it will be accepted and even lauded as being tough and having a sound culture of accountability. But when you're a disappointing team like LSU, well, it will be critisized.

- Im a fan of coach Brohm at L'Ville, but his decision making at the end of the Stanford game was a clinic on how to throw away a game. The simple decision was to just punt and take the game to overtime. Instead it became Murphy's Law that last 30 seconds

- Notre Dame is rolling. Yeah, you can continue to point to the Northern Illinois loss, but they are getting what they wanted from Riley Leonard at quarterback.

- Why has the Heisman talk on Ashton Jeanty died down? At the very least, he should be invited to New York in December.

- Anyone notice the job Kenny Dillinghman is doing at Arizona State in year 2? He should be in the coach of the year discussion.

- Miami had a bye week, so we were all spared from watching that defense. The bottom line for the #Canes is very simple -- it's a three game playoff to get to the playoffs. Lose one, and you're out. Complain all you want about the rankings and bias (I get it) but the ACC is only getting one team in the 12-team tourney

nice post!

I respect Mario for coaching all game long and generally keeping the same energy no matter how the game is going. I really don't know the details of the exchange, but yelling "don't walk away from me...you're un-coachable" at that stage of the season/game is unproductive and seems like a failure of culture-implementation on Kelly's part.

Tuff "old-school coaching" is different than a tirade or the tantrums we used to see from Nick Saban.

As far as Miami, it's nice to get a break from the frustrating offense as well. Hopefully both re-emerge with more sound execution this weekend.
 
Advertisement
Another great Footballpalooza at Coach JB's Football Bar and Cigar Lounge (which was capped off by UFC 309 -- yes, we watched it)..

- Colorado continues to rack up victories. As always, Shaduer Sanders and Travis Hunter will be spotlighted, but the way the Buffs have gotten better defensively is overlooked. Guys like Nikhai Green-Hill and LaVonta Bentley real thumpers, and Amari McNeill have steadily improved. CU is actually a well-rounded team

As for Utah, it's too bad that their QB situation turned out the way it did. It really had an impact on the rest of their team


- The demise of Georgia was exaggerated. But for them to protect their home turf wasn't that big of a surprise. If they get that version of Carson Beck the rest of the way, there are still very few teams that can play with them. As for the Vols, Nico I. has been a disappointment. Not only has he not been worth $8 million, he's not playing at the Hendon Hooker-level, and to be fair, he doesn't have a Jalen Hyatt or Cedric Tillman surrounding him.

- Wasn't completely surprised by Kansas upsetting BYU. The Cougars are another team (like Miami) that had lived on the edge and you get the sense that there would be a week where that caught up to them. The Jayhawks are several plays away from being an 8 win team. They are better than their record

- I see a lot being made over Brian Kelly screaming and yelling at his players. Bottom line, to me, that's old-school coaching. I don't mind it. Football is a tough game. But in today's culture, the optics will not be in his favor. It is what it is. My view is, when you're winning, it will be accepted and even lauded as being tough and having a sound culture of accountability. But when you're a disappointing team like LSU, well, it will be critisized.

- Im a fan of coach Brohm at L'Ville, but his decision making at the end of the Stanford game was a clinic on how to throw away a game. The simple decision was to just punt and take the game to overtime. Instead it became Murphy's Law that last 30 seconds

- Notre Dame is rolling. Yeah, you can continue to point to the Northern Illinois loss, but they are getting what they wanted from Riley Leonard at quarterback.

- Why has the Heisman talk on Ashton Jeanty died down? At the very least, he should be invited to New York in December.

- Anyone notice the job Kenny Dillinghman is doing at Arizona State in year 2? He should be in the coach of the year discussion.

- Miami had a bye week, so we were all spared from watching that defense. The bottom line for the #Canes is very simple -- it's a three game playoff to get to the playoffs. Lose one, and you're out. Complain all you want about the rankings and bias (I get it) but the ACC is only getting one team in the 12-team tourney
I'm going to disagree with you on Louisville. Not in the point that it was a master class in throwing away the game, but in the fact of punting. I take issue with how they proceeded. They were on the 45 with like 35 seconds left and 2 of the 4 downs they took shots down field to score a TD when in reality, they only needed about 10-15 yards over 2-3 plays to get in FG range and win the game.

Even worse was the dumbass db who drew a 15 yard penalty on a 5 yard pass with 5 seconds left in the game.
 
I'm going to disagree with you on Louisville. Not in the point that it was a master class in throwing away the game, but in the fact of punting. I take issue with how they proceeded. They were on the 45 with like 35 seconds left and 2 of the 4 downs they took shots down field to score a TD when in reality, they only needed about 10-15 yards over 2-3 plays to get in FG range and win the game.

Even worse was the dumbass db who drew a 15 yard penalty on a 5 yard pass with 5 seconds left in the game.
I don't think he's ever going to live that down.
 
I don't think he's ever going to live that down.
I was dumbfounded watching it. I was literally thinking, if they hit this fg, he might not make the next trip so he take some time to stew in how stupid the actions were. Man won't be able to practice, because he'll be running steps for the next week.
 
I'm going to disagree with you on Louisville. Not in the point that it was a master class in throwing away the game, but in the fact of punting. I take issue with how they proceeded. They were on the 45 with like 35 seconds left and 2 of the 4 downs they took shots down field to score a TD when in reality, they only needed about 10-15 yards over 2-3 plays to get in FG range and win the game.

Even worse was the dumbass db who drew a 15 yard penalty on a 5 yard pass with 5 seconds left in the game.

yeah, I don't disagree, it wasn't just one thing but a lot of everything in that scenario. Like I said, it was Murphy's Law at the end for Brohm and the Ville...
 
Advertisement
I have to strongly disagree about Brian Kelly. He’s not consistent with that mentality and it only shows up when he’s losing control and throwing a temper tantrum. Mostly throwing players under the bus in excuse for his coaching.

If Brian Kelly’s true nature of being a tough old school coach his players wouldn’t have quit on him because they know he’s fake.

George O’Leary or Nick saban or good recent examples of being consistent ****s and not changing up their persona.

it is what it is at this point that old school coaching style is far and few in between now. It doesn’t really relate well with the new generation of football players.
 
Last edited:
The thing that really shocked me was that BYU lost at home to Kansas, not that they lost a game.

I am hoping Kansas can ride the wave and give Colorado a good game but they may have an emotional let down after that big win..
 
- I see a lot being made over Brian Kelly screaming and yelling at his players. Bottom line, to me, that's old-school coaching. I don't mind it. Football is a tough game. But in today's culture, the optics will not be in his favor. It is what it is. My view is, when you're winning, it will be accepted and even lauded as being tough and having a sound culture of accountability. But when you're a disappointing team like LSU, well, it will be critisized.
I think he’s getting the criticism because everyone knows that he’s an awful person.
 
Advertisement
If some 3 loss SEC team gets in then they better put them in the coldest most miserable Big 10 venue possible just to make their team and southern fans suffer.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top