forums

UM offense vs FSU offense - which one has more tools?

B

bear

Sophomore
Premium
Joined
Jun 14, 2012
Messages
1,615
RB: UM's Duke and Crawford> FSU's Freeman and Wilder
Oline: I take our Oline > FSU
TE: Walford is a beast = O'Fairy (purposely misspelled his name)
WR: Hurns, Waters, Coley, Scott, = Benjamin, Shaw, Green
Qb: Morris<Winston
Punter UM >FSU (this may be a big part of our offense on Saturday - we need them to drive the field.

That is just my take. I debated given FSU the edge on WR...Gave RB to the Canes simply because I will never bet against Duke.

Thoughts?
 
Advertisement
To be honest... I would think both O-lines are a wash and O'Leary ahead of Walford. Their Wide Receivers are probably ahead of ours as well but I think not by much.
 
QB: FSU.... Morris is still a top QB and will prove it against FSU.

RB: Equal..... Duke is the best but FSU has better depth w/ Freeman, Wilder, and Karlos.

WR: Equal..... FSU has a slight edge w/ P. Dorsett out though.

TE: Equal..... O'Leary and Walford both are just as talented (both have "only"17 receptions lol)

OL: Miami.... FSU has a very good O-line but Miami's is better.

DL: Equal

LB: Miami.... Denzel Perryman is the best of the group w/ Telvin Smith a close 2nd. Miami has more players making an impact at LB then FSU.

DB: FSU.... L. Joyner, PJ Williams, R. Darby, J. Ramsey, and T. Brooks win out w/o a 100% Deon Bush and b/c Miami has guys named AJ Highsmith on the 2 deep.
 
Last edited:
Imagine asking this before the season some on here would laugh but the QB spot makes all the difference in the world, so it could kill the myth of certain positions go to certain schools to die. To me its like the dumbest talk to say where TEs go to die, yea of course they do if they have a bad qb its not the uniform that makes them bad. Anyway I take our WR's over theres (actually thinking we could do more with a Winston than SM of course), there TE but our depth, our OL, there RB's (only taking there RB because of Freeman I think his home run ability against good teams is great an depth), and u gotta take Winston over SM.
 
Advertisement
Eh...if Morris was aware of warlord existence he'd have much better stats than the golfers grandson
 
jruiz said:
Eh...if Morris was aware of warlord existence he'd have much better stats than the golfers grandson
Click to expand...

lol who started this point about Walford getting more touches b/c they did a good job explaining it..... now everybody is repeating the samething like it's original.

what's ur point.... Walford dropped a pass against WF so he wouldve had 1 more catch mo then O'Leary if he didnt drop it. "if this that and the third" "coulda woulda" gtfoh w/ that bs talking point.
 
Dwinstitles said:
Imagine asking this before the season some on here would laugh but the QB spot makes all the difference in the world, so it could kill the myth of certain positions go to certain schools to die. To me its like the dumbest talk to say where TEs go to die, yea of course they do if they have a bad qb its not the uniform that makes them bad. Anyway I take our WR's over theres (actually thinking we could do more with a Winston than SM of course), there TE but our depth, our OL, there RB's (only taking there RB because of Freeman I think his home run ability against good teams is great an depth), and u gotta take Winston over SM.
Click to expand...

Quick! Name a TE in the NFL currently or from the past who is from FSU. While you're at it name the last 1,000 yard rusher from FSU.

FSU is where TE's and RB's go to die.
 
Picksix said:
Dwinstitles said:
Imagine asking this before the season some on here would laugh but the QB spot makes all the difference in the world, so it could kill the myth of certain positions go to certain schools to die. To me its like the dumbest talk to say where TEs go to die, yea of course they do if they have a bad qb its not the uniform that makes them bad. Anyway I take our WR's over theres (actually thinking we could do more with a Winston than SM of course), there TE but our depth, our OL, there RB's (only taking there RB because of Freeman I think his home run ability against good teams is great an depth), and u gotta take Winston over SM.
Click to expand...

Quick! Name a TE in the NFL currently or from the past who is from FSU. While you're at it name the last 1,000 yard rusher from FSU.

FSU is where TE's and RB's go to die.
Click to expand...


It doesn't matter, u mean to tell me if Duke Johnson chose fsu he would suck????
Where you go doesn't mean shut if u a baller u a baller period, we put out more because we out recruited them back then when they couldn't evaluate like us. Now evaluations are equal because of exposure to the net. Everyone said Nick O Leary sucked and it seemed true but u need the qb to throw to these open guys. EJ couldn't do it, u mean to tell me coming into the season that fsu O was going to be better than UMs? especially at wr…….everyone thought if your a wr u go to UM, now look what 1 qb baller can do change the wr core. fsu has the same guys and now they are being thrown to when there open and now u see the talent that came from all those number 1 recruiting classes.

QBs change programs and help recruiting, when we land that monster qb we will take off. He might be on the roster now or he might not be we won't know till we see them play.
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
QB: Major edge to FSU (not close)

RB: Miami, if Duke if he is tough and can play the whole game

WR: FSU, with Dorsett out (deep threat) and Scott at a shell of himself. They got us here.

TE: Miami, doesn't matter if we don't throw him the ball

OL: Slight Edge to Miami

Their QB gives them such an advantage, he throws it accurate and incredibly well. He can move well with his legs too. This advantage makes their WRs/TE and RBs perform better too.
 
Last edited:
Consigliere said:
QB: Major edge to FSU (not close)

RB: Miami, if Duke if he is tough and can play the whole game

WR: FSU, with Dorsett out (deep threat) and Scott at a shell of himself. They got us here.

TE: Miami, doesn't matter if we don't throw him the ball

OL: Slight Edge to Miami

Their QB gives them such an advantage, he throws it accurate and incredibly well. He can move well with his legs too. This advantage makes their WRs/TE and RBs perform better too.
Click to expand...

this right here

doesn't matter who's better its who can get them the ball pretty much. Whoever can get there wry and tea the ball better u might as well just give them the edge in all three because it all falls on the qb no matter who's the coach of the offense IMO. qbs get coaches fired and good qbs make coaches hall of famers.
 
Advertisement
Jameis Winston isnt incredibly accurate at all..... their Wide Receivers have made most of the plays on pure talent.
 
Why arent FSU fans *****ing about Nick O'Leary "only" having 17 receptions or being 4th on the team in receptions, unlike Walford who is 2nd?
 
Advertisement
QB-Fsu
RB-Miami
OL-Miami
WRs-Fsu greene is a beast -If the Canes wrs were either,I would pick Miami
Te-Miami
 
Advertisement
Back
Top