From my perspective, and I believe objectively, he’s not doing a good job recruiting, so he’s not doing a good job at all.
I don’t know where you get the idea that he’s doing a good job - if you could point to something specific, that might be helpful.
I’ll point to this: as was mentioned in another post, and as we all know, he blew up his recruiting class when he came in for absolutely no reason. Being a good coach is about making good decisions, and he’s made some horrible ones, including that.