The strategy worked
I won't discuss Beck as a success until the results validate that stance. Only a Miami Hurricane fan would think a Hail Mary followed by another Hail Mary shows proof of concept. [USER=9116]@Rellyrell[/USER] just illustrated to you that Portal QBs are just as much of a crap shoot.
The points you are not willing to discuss that actually matter are.
1. What about the recruiting ramifications for signing project QBs?
2. Why is signing a cheap developmental QB more important than pursuing a talented QB for the long term future like EVERY other contender? (High school or Portal)