The chances of them being true are significantly higher compared to Amber Heards accusations, which havent proven to have any basis yet (which is quite significant). Depp is also extremely well prepared towards the bully tactics of Heards lawyers, one got already fired.
It was either her or a two pound dog.
Two pound dogs do not produce that. They actually showed the pics and as a former dog owner myself, theres no way a two pound dog produced that. 
Well, it couldnt have been that bad if it was a tremendous acting job. The matter of the fact is, at this point, its a landslide victory for Depp, not only because Heards lawyers are ill-prepared, but also because Depps story at this point seems to be far more believable. Even if we take away Depps friends, family and the psychologist he hired away, the statements of the LAPD were clear and shes been caught being extremely abusive and a liar.
I am not even picking a side here, I just love watching this case. You rarely get to see such a case, especially with the amount of information being processed and shown.
I even predict Depps acting career to restart, ngl. Heard has been dragged through the mud so far.
edit: whoops, lets not derail it. back to regular gator ****posting.