bigpurk45
Junior
- Joined
- Feb 21, 2012
- Messages
- 1,536
If I had to pick I would take Taylor, physically he was better in every department
Too close to call, I'm a huge Reed fan so I usually side with him.
Taylor had 14 INTs in 2 years, 3 returned for TDs
Reed had 19 INTs in 3 years, 17 in his last 2 years, 4 returned for TDs
Crazy to think that about our team totals now.
Absolutely sick to have them back to back. If Sean wasn't murdered you could be looking at the top 2 S of all-time IMO.
Not to take anything away from him, but you're comparing Ed Reed's REDSHIRT Junior and Senior years to Sean's TRUE Sophomore and Junior years.
Love Ed, but give me Sean Taylor all day.
How about the best safety not named Ed or Sean.....that dude Darryl Williams.