All-Time Canes Teams Tournament Semi-Final (A)

.


  • Total voters
    32
  • Poll closed .

Dwill4Heisman

#BringBackErickson
Joined
Nov 3, 2011
Messages
6,746
pick 1



Team A

QB-Jim Kelly
WR-Eddie Brown
WR-Roscoe Parrish
WR-Sinorice Moss
RB-Clinton Portis
RB/FB-James Stewart
OT-Jason Fox
OG-Johnathon Feliciano
C-Don Bailey Jr.
OG-AJ Trump
OT-Rashad Butler

DE-Calais Campbell
DT-Orien Harris
DT-Antonio Dixon
DE-Greg Mark
LB-Tavares Gooden
LB-Nate Webster
LB-Darrin Smith
CB-Ryan McNeil
S-Ed Reed
S-Maurice Sikes
CB-Tremain Mack



Team B

QB Steve Walsh
RB Melvin Bratton
FB Alonzo Hoghsmith
TE Bubba Franks
WR Jim Dooley
WR Dale Dawkins
T Matt Patchan
G Kerlin Blaise
C Bobby Garcia
G Mike Hudock
T Mario Cristobal

DE Bill Hawkins
DT Jerome Brown
DT Damione Lewis
DE Kenny Holmes
OLB Jessie Armstead
MLB Dan Morgan
OLB Michael Smith
CB Donnie Ellis
CB Dexter Seigler
S Daryl Williams
S Fred Marion
 
Advertisement
Team B is equal or better in every area. QB, skill positions (RBs, WRs, TEs), OL, DL, LB, DB.

The gap at DL is HUGE.
 
Last edited:
Team A is equal or better in every area. QB, skill positions (RBs, WRs, TEs), OL, DL, LB, DB.

The gap at DL is HUGE.
Not sure you meant that. The B team is far superior at LB and on the DL. Not even comparable.
 
Advertisement
Team B is equal or better in every area. QB, skill positions (RBs, WRs, TEs), OL, DL, LB, DB.

The gap at DL is HUGE.

trying to imagine Don Bailey Jr. and AJ Trump vs. Jerome Brown and Damione Lewis in my head...

Lulz!! This right here...the DL is where team B blows this football game up. No team with "2 Play" Dix at DT should be in a championship of all-time Canes teams. The speed at WR along with Kelly and Reed almost make up for it, but not quite enough for me.
 
Advertisement
Team B is equal or better in every area. QB, skill positions (RBs, WRs, TEs), OL, DL, LB, DB.

The gap at DL is HUGE.

Kelly>>Walsh, best WR is Eddie Brown, best RB is Portis, team B wins front seven by a HUGE margin. Neither OL impresses.
 
Team B is equal or better in every area. QB, skill positions (RBs, WRs, TEs), OL, DL, LB, DB.

The gap at DL is HUGE.

Kelly>>Walsh, best WR is Eddie Brown, best RB is Portis, team B wins front seven by a HUGE margin. Neither OL impresses.

This is based on college, not pros BTW. Highsmith > Portis, IMO. And Bubba Franks is an elite pass catcher. He was a force with Ryan Clements, he'd be unstoppable with a guy like Walsh.
 
Advertisement
Team B is equal or better in every area. QB, skill positions (RBs, WRs, TEs), OL, DL, LB, DB.

The gap at DL is HUGE.

You are a funny guy. Jim Kelly>>>Steve Walsh and it isnt even close.

I love Bratton and Zo but Portis is on a completely different level.

Lmao @ your DB's being better when Team A has THE GOAT CANE (E Reed) and the best corner to ever play here.

Plus, Team A has the best Special Teams in this whole thing. T Mack and Roscoe are top 3 returners in program history.
 
LoL @ Jim Dooley and Dale Dawkins being better than Eddie Brown (one of the GOAT WR's to play here), Roscoe Parrish and Sincorice Moss. Team A's WR's would have a field day against that laughable secondary.
 
LoL @ Jim Dooley and Dale Dawkins being better than Eddie Brown (one of the GOAT WR's to play here), Roscoe Parrish and Sincorice Moss. Team A's WR's would have a field day against that laughable secondary.

You're showing how little you know about Canes football by calling my secondary laughable.

Does Bubba Franks get no credit as part of the receiving core? Either way, with your d-line, Team B would just run it up and down the field all day long and there's no Vinny-T to ***** it up.
 
Advertisement
Team B is equal or better in every area. QB, skill positions (RBs, WRs, TEs), OL, DL, LB, DB.

The gap at DL is HUGE.

You are a funny guy. Jim Kelly>>>Steve Walsh and it isnt even close.

I love Bratton and Zo but Portis is on a completely different level.

Lmao @ your DB's being better when Team A has THE GOAT CANE (E Reed) and the best corner to ever play here.

Plus, Team A has the best Special Teams in this whole thing. T Mack and Roscoe are top 3 returners in program history.

Special Teams wasn't a consideration, so....

You have a safety playing corner and god bless him, but Sikes is easily the worst of the group. I have a pair of AA safeties (who each had long, successful NFL careers, a top CB in Seigler and Ellis who had a chance to be the best ever CB at UM but had a bad injury.

And, in college, Walsh & Kelly is close. Walsh never lost and is responsible for the 2 of the greatest comebacks in the history of the program and those were on the road to boot.
 
Team B is equal or better in every area. QB, skill positions (RBs, WRs, TEs), OL, DL, LB, DB.

The gap at DL is HUGE.

You are a funny guy. Jim Kelly>>>Steve Walsh and it isnt even close.

I love Bratton and Zo but Portis is on a completely different level.

Lmao @ your DB's being better when Team A has THE GOAT CANE (E Reed) and the best corner to ever play here.

Plus, Team A has the best Special Teams in this whole thing. T Mack and Roscoe are top 3 returners in program history.

Special Teams wasn't a consideration, so....

You have a safety playing corner and god bless him, but Sikes is easily the worst of the group. I have a pair of AA safeties (who each had long, successful NFL careers, a top CB in Seigler and Ellis who had a chance to be the best ever CB at UM but had a bad injury.

And, in college, Walsh & Kelly is close. Walsh never lost and is responsible for the 2 of the greatest comebacks in the history of the program and those were on the road to boot.

Zo, Bratton, Walsh, Franks ain't losing to a squad with Antonio Dixon, Calais Campbell and Orien ******* Harris. LMFAO.

This guy bringing up Dooley as a weakness (AA, played both ways, bowl game MVP, 1st round pick) when his roster is putting out that group.
 
LoL @ Jim Dooley and Dale Dawkins being better than Eddie Brown (one of the GOAT WR's to play here), Roscoe Parrish and Sincorice Moss. Team A's WR's would have a field day against that laughable secondary.

You're showing how little you know about Canes football by calling my secondary laughable.

Does Bubba Franks get no credit as part of the receiving core? Either way, with your d-line, Team B would just run it up and down the field all day long and there's no Vinny-T to ***** it up.

Not sure if serious. Calais Campbell was A MONSTER his junior year here. Greg Mark was also a stud.
 
You're talking about Calais Campbell's single good season when discussing All-time Miami teams. Lulz. He's going to do squat with Dixon and Harris next to him.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top