A Way-Too-Early Signing Day Breakdown

ghost2

Retired staff
Premium
Joined
Nov 3, 2011
Messages
5,974
Quarterback (3): Preston Dewey, David Thompson, Gray Crow

An obvious position of need going in, and well-addressed by Golden and Co. No sure-fire superstar, but we did get our 1) heady, well-coached kid that was high on our board from day one, 2) Big, strong-armed underproducer that may turn into something with good coaching, and 3) super-athletic multi-sport athlete. All-in-all, if you're going to take 3 QBs in a class, these are the 3 you take.

Grade - A-


RB (2): Duke Johnson, Danny Dillard

I would have personally loved for us to sign one more big back like Borque or Wes Brown. Under normal circumstances, I'd give this position a B, but knowing how VITAL Duke has been to the success of this recruiting class, I just can't do it.

Grade - A-


WR (6): Malcolm Lewis, Robert Lockhart, Angelo Jean-Louis, Herb Waters, Jontavious Carter, D'Mauri Jones

A big and well-balanced group of kids. Some real studs and a couple potential "reaches" (though I hate that term.) The top 4 (Lewis, Lockhart, AJL, Waters) are as talented as any 4 WR recruits in the nation, IMO. Nice haul!

Grade - A


TE (0-1): Hollifield or bust.

Either way I say bust. Rack 'em up and watch Golden reel in 3 next year.

Grade - F


OL (3): Erick Flowers, Danny Isidora, Taylor Gadbois

I'm going to assume for the moment that Avery Young isn't coming, and it would have been nice to have 4 OL in this class. That said, show me a meaner, tougher trio of man-meat that can move as well as these cats, and I'll show you an all-death-row-inmate production of "The King and I."

Grade - B+


DE (4) - Tyriq McCord, Dwayne Hoilett, Jake O'Donnell, Jelani Hamilton

McCord and Hamilton are beasts and I LOVE O'Donnell's film. ****, I like Hoilett's too - all-in-all, a very nice group.

Grade - B+


DT (3) - Jacoby Briscoe, Earl Moore, DeQuan Ivery

Bodies. Lots of them. That's what we needed. We missed out on some of the big boys (Goldman, Hamilton), but we did fill a need. Nobody here really jumps off the page, though Ivery intrigues me greatly.

Grade - C+


LB (3) - Raphael Kirby, Josh Witt, Gabriel Terry

Another position of need. Losing Northrup hurts - a lot. That said, Kirby is straight beast-mode, and I've read nothing but good things about Witt and Terry. I still would have liked another 1-2 backers in this class.

Grade - C+

DB (8) - Tracy Howard, Deon Bush, Nate Dortch, Vernon Davis, Rayshawn Jenkins, Ladarius Gunter, Antonio Crawford

Holy crap. Seriously, holy crap. Show me a better DB class in the nation. Go on, I dare you. Howard and Bush are the headliners of course, but I LOVE Davis and Crawford. Dortch has serious potential as well. Recruiting job of the year at our most pressing position of need, IMO. Bravo!

Grade - A+

Special Teams (0)

Didn't sign any. Didn't need any.

Grade - INC


Overall Grade: Considering all that Golden went through this year - a team that quit, looming sanctions, 6-6 season, blah blah blah, how can you not appreciate what he's done/is doing here? Final grade of A.
 
Advertisement
ghost......im not as down on LBers as you

in mccord.....odonnell and holliet we have 3 tall.......smaller pure pash rushers who i would expect to see play a hybrid DE/OLB
 
Ghost. Post more.

Pretty generous at the QB position but I like the breakdown. I like the DT's just a little bit more with the addition of Ivery.
 
Advertisement
I would knock QB down to a B and move LBs up to a B/B+. It would have been an A- with Northrup, but you can't win them all.
 
Quarterback (3): Preston Dewey, David Thompson, Gray Crow

An obvious position of need going in, and well-addressed by Golden and Co. No sure-fire superstar, but we did get our 1) heady, well-coached kid that was high on our board from day one, 2) Big, strong-armed underproducer that may turn into something with good coaching, and 3) super-athletic multi-sport athlete. All-in-all, if you're going to take 3 QBs in a class, these are the 3 you take.


Well done

Grade - A-


RB (2): Duke Johnson, Danny Dillard

I would have personally loved for us to sign one more big back like Borque or Wes Brown. Under normal circumstances, I'd give this position a B, but knowing how VITAL Duke has been to the success of this recruiting class, I just can't do it.

Grade - A-


WR (6): Malcolm Lewis, Robert Lockhart, Angelo Jean-Louis, Herb Waters, Jontavious Carter, D'Mauri Jones

A big and well-balanced group of kids. Some real studs and a couple potential "reaches" (though I hate that term.) The top 4 (Lewis, Lockhart, AJL, Waters) are as talented as any 4 WR recruits in the nation, IMO. Nice haul!

Grade - A


TE (0-1): Hollifield or bust.

Either way I say bust. Rack 'em up and watch Golden reel in 3 next year.

Grade - F


OL (3): Erick Flowers, Danny Isidora, Taylor Gadbois

I'm going to assume for the moment that Avery Young isn't coming, and it would have been nice to have 4 OL in this class. That said, show me a meaner, tougher trio of man-meat that can move as well as these cats, and I'll show you an all-death-row-inmate production of "The King and I."

Grade - B+


DE (4) - Tyriq McCord, Dwayne Hoilett, Jake O'Donnell, Jelani Hamilton

McCord and Hamilton are beasts and I LOVE O'Donnell's film. ****, I like Hoilett's too - all-in-all, a very nice group.

Grade - B+


DT (3) - Jacoby Briscoe, Earl Moore, DeQuan Ivery

Bodies. Lots of them. That's what we needed. We missed out on some of the big boys (Goldman, Hamilton), but we did fill a need. Nobody here really jumps off the page, though Ivery intrigues me greatly.

Grade - C+


LB (3) - Raphael Kirby, Josh Witt, Gabriel Terry

Another position of need. Losing Northrup hurts - a lot. That said, Kirby is straight beast-mode, and I've read nothing but good things about Witt and Terry. I still would have liked another 1-2 backers in this class.

Grade - C+

DB (8) - Tracy Howard, Deon Bush, Nate Dortch, Vernon Davis, Rayshawn Jenkins, Ladarius Gunter, Antonio Crawford

Holy crap. Seriously, holy crap. Show me a better DB class in the nation. Go on, I dare you. Howard and Bush are the headliners of course, but I LOVE Davis and Crawford. Dortch has serious potential as well. Recruiting job of the year at our most pressing position of need, IMO. Bravo!

Grade - A+

Special Teams (0)

Didn't sign any. Didn't need any.

Grade - INC


Overall Grade: Considering all that Golden went through this year - a team that quit, looming sanctions, 6-6 season, blah blah blah, how can you not appreciate what he's done/is doing here? Final grade of A.

Nice job
 
Advertisement
I would knock QB down to a B and move LBs up to a B/B+. It would have been an A- with Northrup, but you can't win them all.

This is where I am at. Honestly a C+ to B- is what I was thinking with QB's. I know people are big on Dewey and I like him, but I don't see anything resembling a sure fire prospect in there. Hopefully I am dead wrong.
 
With Blue, I'm willing to give LB a B-/B. He's not in the same league as Northrup, IMO, but it is another body. As for QB, I think we did as well as we could with Morris and Williams in the fold already. We went from 1.5 QBs to 5 QBs - with Dewey and Crow enrolling early, which is HUGE. I think A- is fair for where we are right now.

I'll post more as time permits. I love it here! :stormwarning:
 
Advertisement
Back
Top