I don't disagree with anything you posted here, but I do want to highlight that bolded part. And I think we typically come down on those types when they push too far in the "nastiness" regardless of what side of the fence they all.
On my "new information" comment, when it's about particular recruits, you'll notice I'm not usually one to say "he's coming" or "no way this kid commits here." I like to wait and see. My comment on the new information stuff is really more a commentary on concern over how things are shaping up for December. Right now, things don't look as good as I expected for 2024. But as to any particular recruit, there's no reason for doom and gloom unless an insider says something to that effect.